cross-posted from: https://feddit.online/c/tech@feddit.online/p/2125973/ai-isnt-replacing-your-job-its-turning-it-into-low-paid-gig-work
Platform companies are luring doctors, lawyers, and Ph.D.s with top rates, but then use the same tactics of pay cuts and sudden ghosting that have plagued global data workers.
What a chilling vision of the future of work.
Gig work is so awful in part because it takes more than one tragedy to really take off. You need a workforce tenuous enough that they’ll work in this gross atomised way, competing with fellow workers. You need an economy depressed enough that you can get away with paying them below their actual value. And of course the local labour laws and worker protections have to be weak enough that you can get away with moving in without offering any guarantees that you’ll be a net positive on the region.
In all this the gig platform could be said to be almost innocent, because they didn’t architect any of these awful situations, but like good capitalists they’re happy to exploit them.
That’s not even touching on the private companies who buy the data and rent it back as LLM interactions to workers and other businesses.
In sociology, it’s called McDonaldization. Reduce even the most skilled work to the level of the freedom fryer at a fast food place, and you can reduce everyone to working poverty.
ahhhhhhh glad someone remembers freedom fries 😛 that whole period of time was stupid, was embarrassing ordering at a mcdonalds.
i dunno, being in a time where people were stupid enough to vote trump x3 (dont forget he served fries at mcdonalds) while being all ok with racism and pedophiles has some worthy embarassment and stupidity
In history it was called Deskilling and was a common critique in the Industrial Revolution.
Lowering the skill of a carpenter to pulling a lever.
Haven’t read the article yet, but this is all related to the “atomisation” of labour too: jobs designed so that expertise wouldn’t even benefit them, so that you’re divorced from any of the real levers of power or job satisfaction.
Exactly. I’ve been saying this since day 1.
They won’t replace SWE. Software engineers are paid so much because software is extremely valuable - as a social technology, a good (video games, etc), a research technology, and an industry technology. And more. I don’t know what SWE’s think SWE’s do - but I can assure you the market thinks SWE produce a good. Like a factory worker or farmer, they make a good which is Software.
What happens when you automate large chunks of factory work or farming? The factory workers make less and less and less… but there are still millions of factory workers, a century later. SWE and other information jobs which previously had a moat of information just lost that moat. The job of SWE just got so much easier that now pretty much anyone, day 1 no training, can be as skilled as any NCG. NCG SWE jobs are already bottom rung.
SWE are paid that much because they need accuracy with their coding skills and the ones that make the least amount of mistakes are the most valuable. Not only that there’s older systems too but are being converted into python, like COBOL for example.
You’re not skilled on day one of being a SWE unless you’ve been doing it for months before. Skill comes from experience of doing said action. AI isn’t going to make the field any easier it’s going to keep the people the checkers and static systems will keep being the norm. AI has already proven it makes SWE worse off because of how many errors it produces and humans usually end up making it an actual, working piece of software and are better off going from the ground up; Rather than fixing a bots mistakes to attempt a program that may not even fill the needs of the SWE.
SWEs have always been historically overpaid compared to jobs with similar levels of expertise and education required.
similar doesn’t mean the same level and overpaid always sounds like a jealousy thing. Doctors, Lawyers and Athletes are all, “overpaid,” too but so is a nurse practitioner by that example. The tech sector varies by location. If you’re in Ohio you’re not doing much being a coder, if you’re in Boston, you’re making bank.
Air traffic controller swe and coders make bank. What and who you’re coding for matters too. Yeah it can be similar but the knowledge and skill level is not the same.
lol, i am not a coder or an swe
SWEs apparently cuck code these days or babysit LLMs.
I won’t find any presentation at a conference instructive “oh, I wrote this prompt” and kept carving at it. Me: “But what exactly does it do?”
Do they even “code review” anymore since they’re “code reviewing the LLM?” They are training their replacements. Sure, it may not be 100% replacement, but maybe a clean 60% replacement and the remaining 40% are weird LLM managers.
SWEs apparently cuck code
forced to be cuck-coders is more like it.
Yeah LLM produces code & architecture of a much higher quality than most SWE’s these days. The value a swe provides these days is mostly translating PM & designer desires into the automated flows to mutate the product, but that is low-skill work with LLM now.
Even if you feel LLM produced code is only 80% as good, a company would JUMP at the chance to get an 80%-quality product for 5% the cost.
You should not let your emotions about AI, LLM, wage compression, and so on blind you from the realities. You wanting LLM to be bad at coding will not make it so, even if you call it cuck coding.
That is because most SWEs are disinterested in the craft
Can it produce any of this without an actual dev though? Maybe I’m living in the past still reading code, but of the PRs coming across my desk, it’s painfully obvious which ones were written or at least curated by someone who knew what they were doing.
I’m a hobbyist at coding not a pro but to me it seems the key issue is how necessary that distinction.
AI can produce hours of content - like we see with the AI Odyssey. But the problem is humans love stories / movies. And they want them to be human and good.
A lot of software exists to solve a business problem and so long as it mostly works no one cares if it’s good. SAP, quick books, Salesforce, blue yonder, mcleod, oracle… don’t need to be entertaining or even particularly easy to use or have a neat UI - they need to make money faster than not using them.
I feel like SWE is becoming more like acting though - the already rich, famous and well connected get to make the best stuff for fun, the average Joe is stuck doing the software equivalent of an educational shakespeare tour to high school.
Yeah the world of work and business has no defenses against something like a token renting model if it helps push paperclips faster.
It’s the same thing with managed services, cloud computing, etc. Like I’d rather eat my foot than work with Amazon or AWS, or Salesforce, but try telling that to an employer (I have)—they are helpless to resist the financial machine.
And it only seems like these giant companies are getting more brazen in their anti-worker practices, as it’s clear that smaller companies will excuse any perfidy against workers and the environment, against our collective future, until it’s their turn to get drained for the investors (by which time it will be too late to resist, ofc).
I earned $300 today on a side gig repairing something someone thought they could use AI to fix
Anecdotally, I see far more job ads for technical writers post-AI than I did pre-AI. Someone needs to clean up all the slop!
Where do you find this? Might be a good pivot for me.
Just on indeed and other similar job ad sites
I’ve seen a few people on linkedin with the self proclaimed title “ai cleanup specialist”
I love that for them. :D
I got my current position because my resume was very obviously never “augmented” by AI.
Yeah I was looking for work recently, and the very lowest my callback rate on job applications never dropped below 8% when I handwrote all my job applications. It was nice knowing I could apply to 10 jobs and at least expect to hear back from one of them.
This was just before companies started doing fake screener interviews using ai, so maybe that number would be closer to 100% now lol. Which would actually suck for screening out employers who are serious enough to be considered.
Every billionaire’s wet dream. Bypass all labor protections. Shit, gig work was invented because the only way to find more efficiencies in those sectors was to misclassify employees as contractors.
Many years ago skilled craftspeople rebelled against the industrial revolution turning their jobs into shitty lowpaying factory work and were executed for doing so. Now it’s 200 years later and the wealthy are turning the jobs of skilled professionals into lowpaying gig work. It is their dream that one day we will all be stuck doing lowpaying shit jobs, while they sit on their asses all day drinking fancy champagne. We need to eat the rich or else this is our future.
So how about a workers revolution. We all stop. We all halt the means of production then. No coders or SWE to fix any of the shit ai code, they all lose.
No one to fix their roads to their fancy mansions, no one to keep them alive with a monkey heart transplant, no one to provide them with building materials, no one to provide them with liquor, no one to clean their homes.
We can all stop everything and they’ll either spend money on robots or start killing us either way the world is watching. That would take so long before they’d even waste their money on robots they’d rather waster their money on the scabs.
How about halting the means of production for what they use the most, how about we all start denying services to the mega super rich people? Just because they have the money doesn’t mean we have to comply to them.
We are in control of the services and goods they use. We can stop saying yes to them and their heads will spin and try to create another private sector of what we refuse to do but then guess what!!
The future employees can just never become employees and no one can apply and every one can ignore their cries for help.
It’s not morally wrong to stop helping someone you don’t like.
We can lower our empathy to stop helping them with anything down to medical care, seriously there could be places where they go, “ohhhh we can’t accept money from people who earn as much as you.” Stop allowing them to buy things stop allowing them to be able to use our goods and services. Shut off their natgas, shut off their water, shut off their electricity, deny their car payments, deny them medical services, make zoning for their areas impossible to live freely under and make it so that if they commit a bribe they do go to jail and their bribe burned in front of them.
We control everything, not them. The pipes, the electrical lines, the internet access, the building of houses, everything the common man runs is what we control and what they need, if we stop giving them access to society… maybe that wouldn’t be a bad thing
WE CONTROL ACCESS TO SOCIETY NOT THEM, WE CONTROL EVERYTHING BECAUSE WE KNOW HOW TO RUN THEM AND OPERATE THEM. ALL THE RICH CAN DO IS HIRE.
its ultimately crazy though that we’re at the point of wanting to segregate people from society based on the amount of money and influence they hold over society, didn’t take too long.
Ever since Feudalism ended that they’ve been trying to bring Feudalism back, this time with the Burgeousie at the top.
while they sit on their asses all day drinking fancy champagne.
People don’t seem to understand that’s capitalism. You work, they profit. You say “capitalism is bad” and they think you want like forced relocation to a farm, or government mandated tooth brushes.
I just want people who do work to profit from their work. I’ll even concede that “leadership” can be a kind of labor - someone has to go on TV - but none of this nonsense where some ghoul shits out a PowerPoint and makes like four days of someone useful’s wage
I’ll even concede that “leadership” can be a kind of labor
I have come around to this myself. It’s a bit immaterial, but it’s handy to have someone to manage things, herd us cats etc. Obviously it shouldn’t give you outsized control over hundreds of people against their consent.
Same thing with landlords. Fixing clogged sinks, calling contractors, shoveling the driveway are all real work. Owning a house is not. You shouldn’t get anything for that other than a house to live in.
So basically a superintendent, I guess.
Yeah exactly. The guy who sweeps the lobby and is on call when there’s a leak is doing work. The guy who just owns the place on paper for the “passive income” is doing little to none.
I lost a bit of respect for an old coworker when he went down the landlord path. Bought a cheap place and made it an Airbnb, and doesn’t work anymore. He’s so proud. Fuck him. The money he’s pulling in is way out of proportion with the work he’s doing.
I’ll even concede that “leadership” can be a kind of labor
Organising, structuring and coordinating work from multiple people is definitely an important job, and not everyone has the aptitude for it. We just need to get rid of the idea that it’s the only or primary career advancement, or that it’s inherently a superior position.
And we really need to get rid of the pathological need to optimise shit for arbitrary measures of growth at all costs and blindly rewarding managers that “make line go up”.
The pay situation is a bit better in cultures where seniority matters more (eg: Japan). As you age, your salary increases (beyond inflation adjustment), without consideration of your work. If you get promoted, it’s a larger increase but you get a base raise anyways.
This adds some complacency and slow moving traditions but not everything needs to move fast and break stuff.
I remember talking to a bus driver who was making significantly more than me and I was a white collar worker in a highly paid position. When I remarked on it, he said: it’s ok, because as one ages, one has more knowledge and responsibility in personal life and work and the pay reflects that.
NGL, I kinda liked that there’s a place where society thinks like this
Wow it saddens me that I can hardly fathom that kind of sense of dignity baked into a society.
The real issue with capitalism is that the person with the money calls the shots. Want to start a business and run it differently? Be a worker coop? Well, eventually you are going to need to get investors to get the working capital needed to grow. Guess what? Once you do that those people are now your boss, and they have their own idea of how a business should be run. Usually they are incredibly greedy too, so they will meddle and force decisions that they think will make them profit more, faster.
IMO the private capital system should be replaced with or have alongside a public grant system. Similar setup with series A B etc funding and milestones, but instead of a private equity group or family office it’s a public agency that provides the funds and monitors your progress. Get rid of the investor greed engine and replace it with a stability engine.
If a company is successful enough to IPO, the public become shareholders. People can still invest like they do today, it’s just your board contains civil servants.
Part of the problem is that money is tied exclusively to profitability not to how much society wants/needs something. Those things are similar, but not the same. The system rewards companies for leaving someone else holding the bag, outsourcing negative externalities, etc. We need another way to monitor and measure success that isn’t just money made.
Another good step would be making companies clean up their messes, even when it’s hard to quantify. Oil companies should clean up spills even if it bankrupts them. Loggers should plant trees for every tree they cut and manage a healthy diverse forest, brewers and distillers should pay to have late-night public transit extended through a cities entertainment district to cut drunk driving. This also means paying your employees and any that you put into unemployment. The “pay me, fuck everyone else” attitude needs to stop.
Another good step would be making companies clean up their messes, even when it’s hard to quantify.
Capturing externalized costs would be great.
People would whine that they can’t have their disposable plastic, but I don’t think that whining is more merited than my whining about not wanting a world full of micro plastics.
Maybe that means a lot of things are infeasible. Fine. Spend some of the billions of dollars going into AI slop on renewable energy and containers that safely biodegrade when they’re done. Build transit that’s not extremely dirty cars. If the rich are so fucking smart they can find a solution, right?
Capitalism would fight this sort of thing to the death. It just wants profit, even if it poisons the world and everyone else.
Agreed, also those solutions do not need to be super complex and require large corporations, nor the sacrifice of our rights to make them work. If we didn’t use poverty as a threat for people who don’t fall in line, I bet urban camping along streams would fall and watershed contamination would drop as a result. Not every change has to be about making people comply with the ruling class’ vision of the world using economic and physical violence. Sometimes we can just follow things because it’s the right thing for our collective future.
There is actually a pretty easy alternative to measuring success: what is the median salary of all your employees, and what is your fire to hire ratio?
Quite frankly, I think those metric should be factored into the tax code for corporations. I’d you fired more than you hired, but also demonstrate profitability, you get a severe penalty. If the salary curve at you company is too steep, you get a penality.
The only thing these people understand is money, so we need to deal with it in the tax code.
I once worked, briefly, for the employer with the highest W2 turnover in the entire county (by widespread rumor, not verified). They would have paid a lot more taxes under your plan and I wouldn’t feel bad about it one bit. I came in every day wanting to quit. Even the employee who trained me had a little rhyme to remember the door code that was all about quitting.
Yes, the private tyranny stuff is also a big problem with capitalism.
It’s funny because the US claims to love democracy (itself a dubious claim), but then loves, without remark, the utter tyranny of our private systems. The boss tells you when you can piss, when you can eat, what you can wear. If the government did that, outrage. But because there’s a paper thin “you can choose to quit your job” people see it as freedom.
anyone with a reasonable amount of wealth can quit their job, working paycheck to paycheck is a big issue and the companies love it.
I get it, that’s what I want as well. You may have heard of how hard it is for new grads to find work right now and I’m one of them. It makes me feel like I’m never gonna get hired which I’m sure is intentional so we’re more accepting of shitty conditions if we do get hired. Fuck capitalism.
then they will build thier bougie fancy Enclave cities free from the poors. everyone outside is destitute.
This seems true based on some cold headhunter emails I’ve been getting to “check AI’s work” for piecemeal pay. I’d rather work at Costco fetching carts
costcos in my area apparently doesnt hire often, because people are treated so good, that people dont leave the company, so its pretty hard to get a job there.
I’m not sure if I’d actuallly go as far as working at costco, but I might start my own business if nobody’s hiring for decent jobs anymore.
I considered that for myself, but my skill set is pretty niche and R&D funding has mostly dried up under this admin, so when this job ends it’ll probably be a step down (and across) to some safer harbor.
It’s genuinely cool that have to option to strike off on your own!
That’s a fair concern. I’m a software developer and I don’t see myself start a software concultancy firm in this day and age. Maybe I could try to make and sell some app or framework, but that’s still very unlikely since I don’t have too much experience. The wife and I already have a plan to start a b&b on the side, maybe we’ll do that fulltime.
What’s a b&b
Bed and breakfast, it’s a cheap and simple accomodatiom where people can sleep while they are on vacation or traveling. Usually people have a spare room or a renovated barn that they rent out to travelers, it varies a lot. Think of “air b&b”, but without the corporate greed and the scams
Bed and breakfast is what makes sense to me in context, but I’m not OP.
In this economy, most companies looking to hire you are going to likely already be using AI shortcuts.
I’m still employed mostly because AI is creating security issues and I’m one of the most technical people on staff… But even so, I give it a year or two at the most at this point.
The issue isn’t just AI, it’s idiot CEO’s. My own CEO told me to hook our websites directly into an LLM. Just the most asinine shit…
This is the correct answer.

Who knows, if you carry out the role with aplomb and show rigorous initiative, you might even get promoted to cart nark status; it would mean more responsibility, but the perks of regularly discharging polite but assertive words at random people whom are probably disgruntled, could offer a potential workplace injury claim?
The only problem I could see arising, being the branch responsible for conducting the assessment would probably be A.I. as well as the appeal process…
Yeah.
If my job as a dev is just checking AI stuff, I’ll go do something else.
Why are they going after technically complicated stuff when they can’t do basic shit yet? I work as a groundskeeper at a university. Every year they send me to the biggest trade show in the region to check out new tech. For the past five years, its all been trash bots that are completely incapable of handling our work. The most advanced mowing drones still can’t handle hills. Don’t even get me started on snow clearing, anything more than a light flurry causes immediate failures. There hasn’t been a single viable option for us in any capacity as far as new tech is concerned.
My boss thinks AI is a great tool for planning gardens. Every garden we’ve “updated” using his methods promptly died because the AI doesn’t understand the climate requirements of plants or how climate change has altered the traditional zones used for garden planning. They’re currently in the process of replacing him over this and other AI inspired bullshit.
I am ABSOLUTELY confident I will be able to make it to retirement without machines taking my job at this point. I do exactly the sort of labour they said robots and machine learning will replace first. They don’t even have the tech to replace our janitors. There’s no way they’re replacing technical skills without massive catastrophes throughout society. Buckle up folks!
AI does not need to be competent for you to lose your job. A snake oil salesman just has to convince your boss. The danger is the same as it has ever been: how stupid is your boss?
In a university? I believe Pratchett had a good quote for that…
“There were times when the desire to climb the thaumaturgical ladder was seriously blunted, and one of them was when you saw what was on top.”
It does when you work a job that creates huge liability issues when done poorly at one of the top 3 universities in your country, top 40 worldwide. They get sued a half dozen times every winter even when we do a good job. They’re not taking any chances on shit machines they can’t insure or hold liable when shit goes sideways.
No way they’re replacing tech skills without massive catastrophies? That’s ridiculous!
It was completely coincidental that Microsoft, the FAA, the NSA, 911, and Chase all went down catastrophically within 72 hours of eachother!
And the BBC, CNN, Equifax, Ledger, Zoom, and hundreds of other mainstream websites serving malware at the same time? Also coincidence!
Everything is fine and no one who has access to the inner workings of these things has been building bunkers.
Yeah, the FAA incident may or may not be related, but it certainly seems just like an averted disaster at my workplace where someone proposed a Claude translated network config to go from one vendor to another and I had to manually interject and insist on a review and found that claude completely screwed up something that would have done… well pretty much exactly what happened to the FAA, had it been actually applied.
The banking issue they flat out mentioned it was AI related, but they only explicitly admitted it was trying to remedy an AI detected security issue. Question is whether they took the AI suggested remediation and got screwed by it, or if a human boffed the remediation, and it’s tough to say without the bank coming out and being explicit about it.
Microsoft came out kind of vague and said some change was made to Windows OS in July that caused the catastrophe that they had to unwind. Again light on detail, but given their excessive public bullishness on full on agentic AI and the sort of change described, it’s almost certainly a vibed change in pursuit of what would likely be considered a premature optimization. Huge risk, no reward sort of change for the sake of someone’s AI KPIs, probably.
A bit grumpy because in my work, I try to be as hard on the AI skepticism as my company will take, and onboarded a pretty all-in AI coder and thought I had at least gotten them to actually make sure their change at least specifically did as they intended, and not merely passed the automated test suites. I sat with him interactively on some pull requests to make sure he actually made a plan to try out his changes and validate the behavior with his own eyes, and thought I instilled a good habit. So shocker as the first ‘big test’ after I trusted that he actually vetted some of his changes fell over. His pull request even explicitly listed the scenarios and claimed that each one was tried. He then had to admit that Claude just made up that it tested the scenarios tested but he figured it was a safe bet if Claude ‘audited’ it that it was ok if it lied about actually trying the scenario…
I’ve always believed this, but now I know the right term for it. Thank you kind sir!
That link doesn’t work for me, but it was an interesting read! And it makes very much sense.
Seeing if this link works better: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec's_paradox
Edit: nope, same problem… Seems my app interprets % as %25, which returns %2527 instead of %27
That’s obvious. What did evolution have to figure out first? Perception and mobility, or playing checkers?
They wouldn’t replace all the workers. They’d replace all the ones operating the mowers and leafblowers and such, and just have one person stand by to supervise the entire thing in case the machines fuck up. Kinda like how self-checkouts work now.
funny how even self-checkout ended up, being unreliable as it allow people to steal unabated, and they more or less eliminated in many stores. i see this happening with the workers, they will just hire less people back to do more WORK.
Idiocracy creeps ever closer.
I just got banned from one of these platforms. It was hell working that job. I really need money though.
Everyone is constantly paranoid about getting banned. They require invasive logging to be installed. Everything is monitored. It’s micromanagment on steroids.
One moment you’re looking at a picture of a thing, intensely scrutinizing it, hoping you’re working fast enough too. Suddenly the page auto redirects to a ban message. All your access is revoked. I spent a year fearing that every single day and it finally hit me. People wake up every morning to check and see if they’re not removed.
My mind turns to mush grinding out data labelling/validation all day long. The pressure to meet rate and not mess up is intense. Your work is graded and you receive a score on each submission. It’s a lot of pressures.
They are rolling out full time positions. So expect to see that in the coming year. I personally could not do 40 hours of this a week. This a consensus among workers too. There was chatter about roughly 4 to 6 hours a day of this kind of work at the most. Some did say they log the full amount of time we were alotted per week. That’s 10 or 12 hour days. Could you scrutinize photos for 12 hours a day? You have do it on an average of let’s say 2 or 3 minutes per photo. It usually require quick write up about it. It has to be perfect so as to not induce errors in the AI. You will receive a grade on each submission which is done by another worker like you who is under the same pressures.
I’ve seen some of work people submit. Quite frankly the impoverished and less educated regions submit junk data. There’s no other way to say it. There’s more errors. The clarity of writing is worse too. Language models are pedantic about phrasing so fluency matters.
They appear to be favoring workers from western regions lately. That’s only my gut feeling though. The pay can be quite high if you’re a professional in just about any field. Not only STEM. I personally did not see them pull tactics to reduce pay. Mine actually went up. I have heard the stories though. They pay third world countries a fraction of what they pay western countries for the same work. Then again, the quality kind of reflects that.
Some who have done the job of reviewing work have expressed negative feelings about it. The job is to review other’s ability to label data. But they’re determining someone’s livelihood. Other’s don’t care. Some relish in the power they get from it.
ETA: I forgot to mention. My computer would randomly lag while working. I assume it was whatever invasive surveillance their software was doing.
They brought piece work to the tech industry. That’s what they did. If they’re making you purchase your own setup, it’s piecework. That’s what you’re describing.
Yep. Older generations of my family did piecework back in the day too. Initially I hadn’t thought about that. It came to me a few months into doing it. We’ve circled back to where we were a few generations ago.
Piecework is about fixed rate, but this is essentially what it is because we’re measured by the rate of submissions. Some projects are hourly pay. Others paying per unit of production.
Some companies are quite bad. They won’t pay for submissions that get a low grade. If it takes too long then the submission is paid lower or not at all.
Cool write-up, thank you
Basically we will transit from skilled craftsmen to low skill machine operators
There are no low skill operators in knowledge work, you either know the domain or you don’t. Hiring someone off the streets to rubber stamp guesswork doesn’t change that equation.
They’re not hired to know the domain. They’re hired as scapegoats when slop generator inevitably fucks up big.
Blaming underpaid workers in a developing country sounds like the weakest scapegoat ever but maybe the shareholders will go for it.
shareholders love that shit, because it shows that the company is being ‘accountable’ without replacing the executive staff.
So…it IS replacing my job with a lower paid one. That’s what that word means.
This work is driven by the big tech companies, like Google. They contract it out. They are very aggressive with rates and quality. Google does not even allow for rate increases based on minimum wage increases for the workers in a given locale.
…because its replacing you at your old job!












